Moving to Long Island: Your Complete Guide to Life, Neighborhoods Estate

Moving to Long Island: What to Know Before You Make the Move

Why So Many New Yorkers Are Heading East

If you’ve been dreaming about trading city noise for ocean breeze, you’re not alone. Over the past few years, Long Island has become one of the most sought-after destinations for people looking for more space, better schools, and a slower pace — without giving up access to New York City. Whether you’re relocating from the city, another state, or just moving to a new town on the Island, this guide covers what makes Long Island such a great place to call home.

1. The Lay of the Land

Long Island stretches about 120 miles from Brooklyn to Montauk Point, and it’s divided into four main counties: Kings (Brooklyn), Queens, Nassau, and Suffolk. Most people moving to “the Island” are looking at Nassau or Suffolk County, where suburban life thrives — from vibrant downtowns like Huntington Village and Patchogue to peaceful beach towns like Oyster Bay and Sag Harbor.

Nassau tends to offer shorter commutes and more established neighborhoods, while Suffolk provides more land, quieter surroundings, and a closer connection to nature.

2. Housing and Real Estate Trends

The Long Island housing market remains competitive but diverse. You’ll find classic Capes and Colonials, modern new builds, and even historic waterfront estates. Prices vary dramatically depending on proximity to NYC and the coast.

• Nassau County median home price (2025): Around $725,000

• Suffolk County median home price (2025): Around $585,000

While prices have stabilized compared to the pandemic surge, inventory remains tight, especially in commuter-friendly towns near the LIRR. Buyers who come prepared — with pre-approval and a local agent — tend to have the edge.

3. Commuting and Transportation

One of Long Island’s biggest perks is accessibility. Thanks to the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR), many residents can commute into Manhattan in under an hour. Towns like Garden City, Mineola, Babylon, and Ronkonkoma are particularly popular for their direct train lines and bustling downtowns near the station.

If you drive, major roadways like the Long Island Expressway (I-495) and Northern State Parkway connect nearly every part of the Island — though rush hour can be a test of patience (locals know to time their trips wisely).

4. Schools and Family Life

Long Island is famous for its top-rated public schools, often ranking among the best in New York State. Districts like Jericho, Great Neck, and Half Hollow Hills consistently earn high marks for academics and extracurriculars. Combine that with safe neighborhoods, plenty of parks, and year-round activities, and it’s easy to see why so many families choose to settle here.

5. Lifestyle and Things to Do

Living on Long Island means you’re never far from the water. Locals love spending summer weekends at Jones Beach, Robert Moses, or Fire Island, while North Fork wineries and Hamptons farm stands make weekend getaways a way of life.

Foodies are spoiled too — from fresh seafood shacks in Montauk to Italian favorites in Port Washington. And if you crave city life, Manhattan is just a train ride away.

6. Cost of Living

It’s no secret — living on Long Island can be pricey. Property taxes are among the highest in the country, and utilities and groceries can add up. That said, residents often find the trade-off worth it for the quality of life, community feel, and access to excellent schools and beaches. Smart budgeting and working with a local real estate professional can help you find the right fit for your lifestyle and finances.

7. Finding the Right Neighborhood

Before you make the move, spend time exploring different areas. Ask yourself:

• Do you need an easy NYC commute?

• Are schools a top priority?

• Do you prefer suburban bustle or quiet coastal charm?

Each Long Island town has its own personality — from the artsy vibe of Northport to the surfer energy of Long Beach or the historic appeal of Port Jefferson. A local agent who knows the nuances of each community can make all the difference.

FAQs About Moving to Long Island

Q: Is Long Island a good place for families?
Absolutely. Long Island is known for its excellent schools, safe neighborhoods, and abundance of family-friendly activities year-round.

Q: How long is the commute to Manhattan?
Depending on where you live, LIRR travel times range from 35 minutes (Garden City) to about 90 minutes (Riverhead).

Q: What are property taxes like?
Taxes vary by town but generally range between 2–3% of a home’s assessed value. Always check local rates before buying.

Q: Are there affordable areas on Long Island?
Yes — communities in Eastern Suffolk, like Shirley, Mastic, and Riverhead, tend to be more affordable while still offering great quality of life.

Q: What’s the best time to move to Long Island?
Spring and early summer are peak moving seasons, but fall can offer less competition and better deals for buyers.

Thinking About Making the Move?

If Long Island sounds like the lifestyle you’re after, start exploring neighborhoods now. From waterfront living to small-town charm, there’s truly a spot for everyone here — and having a local real estate guide makes all the difference when finding your perfect home.